Cheta Nwanze, Lead Partner, SBM Intelligence

Follow Cheta Nwanze

View Profile


Subjects of Interest

  • Fiscal Policy
  • Geopolitical Analysis
  • Governance
  • Politics

Why Nigerian economic reform requires better data 16 Nov 2026

Last month, Taiwo Oyedele, Nigeria’s Minister of Finance and Coordinating Minister of the Economy, addressed an audience at Chatham House on the state of the country's economy and the government's reform agenda. The presentation offered an opportunity to assess both the progress achieved and the challenges that remain.

Macroeconomic stability featured prominently in his speech. Nigeria’s headline inflation stood at 14.63 per cent in September, down from 21 per cent a year earlier. Core inflation had declined to 12.95 per cent, while month-on-month inflation was recorded at just 0.06 per cent. Gross external reserves reached $55 billion on 9 October, their highest level in almost eighteen years, while net reserves increased from roughly $3 billion three years ago to more than $46 billion.

The growth outlook was similarly positive. The World Bank projects economic growth of 4.3 per cent this year, rising to 4.4 per cent over the next two years. Mr Oyedele suggested that these projections may be conservative, noting that the government's medium-term objective is to achieve average annual growth of approximately 7 per cent over five years.

He also highlighted key elements of the government's reform programme. The removal of the petrol subsidy, which authorities estimate generated N15.8 trillion in savings by the end of 2025, remains in place. The exchange rate has been unified. The Tax Reform Acts of 2025 have simplified a previously fragmented tax framework. Social interventions have also expanded, with more than ten million households now receiving digitally verifiable cash transfers linked to National Identity Numbers.

The most significant part of the presentation, however, was the acknowledgement that important challenges remain. Food inflation, at 19.6 per cent, continues to outpace headline inflation. While overall price pressures have eased, essential food prices remain a major source of hardship, particularly for lower-income households.

Mr Oyedele identified several causes of the situation: low agricultural productivity, seasonal supply disruptions, post-harvest losses, inadequate storage facilities, weak logistics networks, high transport costs, and insecurity in farming communities. He argued that addressing these constraints will require sustained supply-side interventions and will inevitably take time.

I attended the event and, during the question-and-answer session, raised the issue of transport costs. Research by SBM Intelligence has consistently shown that transport is among the most significant drivers of food price instability across the South-South region and in several other parts of the country. I therefore asked what policy measures the government intended to pursue in this area.

His response was revealing not only for what it suggested about infrastructure but also for highlighting a broader challenge in economic policymaking.

Mr Oyedele began with a point about measurement. If road conditions are poor this year and remain equally poor next year, their contribution to inflation is effectively neutral because inflation measures changes over time rather than absolute conditions. The disinflationary impact comes when conditions improve.

He then turned to a more practical concern. The cost of transporting agricultural produce across the country has become a significant burden. Truck operators transporting yam from northern Nigeria to southern markets reportedly budget around N700,000 per trip. These transportation costs are ultimately reflected in the final retail price, with consumers bearing the burden.

That observation is important because it highlights a broader issue. It offers policymakers valuable insight into inflationary pressures, yet it is not the type of information captured by most official statistical series. That gap between what is measured and what is needed for policymaking emerged as a recurring theme throughout the discussion.

The Gap Between What We Measure and What We Need

Mr Oyedele was unusually candid about the country's statistical challenges. According to him, the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) remains underfunded and lacks the resources required to undertake many of the surveys needed for effective policymaking. Existing indicators often reveal outcomes without fully explaining their causes.

For example, the Consumer Price Index measures changes in consumer prices but does not identify the underlying drivers of those changes. Nigeria also lacks a comprehensive Producer Price Index, limiting policymakers' ability to distinguish between cost-push and demand-pull inflation. This distinction matters because monetary tightening is effective against some inflationary pressures but far less so against others. As the Central Bank transitions to an inflation-targeting framework, the quality and completeness of economic data become even more important. Effective inflation targeting requires a robust statistical infrastructure, which remains a work in progress.

Oyedele was equally forthright about fiscal planning. He noted that public budgets have historically been built on revenue projections that often diverge sharply from realised outcomes. Revenue performance has frequently fallen 40 to 60 per cent below projections. Because each year's budget traditionally begins with the preceding year's assumptions rather than actual outturns, forecasting errors can compound over time.

He assured that efforts are underway to address these shortcomings, including the move towards a single consolidated budget framework. Yet the broader challenge is institutional. Political systems naturally favour optimistic projections because the immediate costs of realism are often higher than the short-term costs of optimism. Improving fiscal credibility therefore requires scrutiny by independent institutions, analysts, researchers, and the media.

The data challenge extends beyond budgets and macroeconomic indicators. A survey commissioned by the Ministry of Finance found that households spent as much as 120 per cent of their monthly income on food. This figure reflects coping mechanisms such as borrowing and deferred payments. Understanding these realities is essential to designing effective social protection programmes, but only detailed, sustained data collection can capture them.

A similar issue arises with tax administration. Nigeria’s tax-to-GDP ratio is a closely watched indicator that influences perceptions of fiscal capacity, investment attractiveness, and sovereign risk. Yet recent estimates differ significantly. While the World Bank reported 7.5 per cent, the government's own estimate is 12.5 per cent.

A five-percentage-point discrepancy in such a fundamental indicator is not trivial. It creates uncertainty for investors, analysts, and ratings agencies, ultimately affecting the country's cost of borrowing. As Oyedele noted, a country should be able to provide authoritative data on a metric as important as its tax effort.

His broader message was clear: policymaking depends on reliable evidence. In his words, "In God we trust. All others must bring data."

What the Jollof Index Has Learned

These observations align closely with our experience at SBM Intelligence. Since 2016, SBM Intelligence's Jollof Index has tracked the cost of preparing a pot of jollof rice across selected Nigerian markets. Over that period, the index has diverged materially from official food inflation data only once. This consistency is not the result of an attempt to replicate official statistics. Rather, both datasets measure the same underlying economic reality. When independent methodologies produce similar outcomes, confidence in the findings increases.

At the same time, the index has highlighted limitations in existing data systems.

Last quarter, the national Jollof Index recorded an 11.5 per cent decline. However, after identifying and correcting a recording anomaly in Ibadan, where curry and thyme prices were incorrectly recorded at N3,500 between January and June before falling to N650 from July onward, the actual decline was closer to 8.5 per cent.

Both figures were published, and the methodology was explained transparently. Accurate data requires not only collection but also accountability and openness about errors.

The index also captures information that official datasets often miss. Traders in Kano, for instance, reported multiple police checkpoints and informal, vigilante collection points along key transport routes. In Bauchi, some traders said refusal to make unofficial payments could result in delays significant enough to spoil perishable goods. These payments, ranging from N500 to N1,000, may not appear in formal inflation measures or budget documents, yet they influence the prices consumers ultimately pay.

The index further documents the uneven transmission of falling prices. Perishable goods often reflect lower input costs immediately, whereas proteins usually adjust within a few days. Packaged products may take weeks to reprice, depending on location. In some markets, inventories must be substantially depleted before retailers pass lower costs on to consumers. These dynamics help explain why improvements at the farm gate often take time to materialise in household budgets.

The Port Harcourt Problem

The value of granular data is perhaps most evident in Port Harcourt, the only major market covered by the index where prices rose during the quarter.

Severe flooding affected the city throughout the third quarter, damaging fish and poultry farms and disrupting transport networks. State inflation accelerated from 14.0 per cent in July to 19.1 per cent in August, even as national inflation continued to decline.

Floods distort markets in complex ways. Damaged goods may be sold at deeply discounted prices, while unaffected goods become scarcer and more expensive. Conventional price surveys tend to capture only part of this reality.

The resulting data is not necessarily inaccurate. Rather, it may be incomplete. Significant volumes of economic activity occur outside the pricing structures that most inflation indices are designed to capture. As such, national averages provide a useful broad picture, but they can obscure important local variations. Markets with different conditions require closer analysis. This is why disaggregated and market-level data remain indispensable.

The Narrative Cost

A final theme addressed by Mr Oyedele concerned Nigeria's international economic reputation. He argued that perceptions of risk often impose additional costs on the country in the form of higher borrowing costs and reduced investment flows. While some concerns are justified, others stem from incomplete or outdated narratives. 

Importantly, he suggested that these perceptions are not driven solely by foreign observers. Nigerians frequently amplify negative developments while discounting positive ones, creating a narrative imbalance that can affect international assessments.

He expressed scepticism about proposals for a new African credit rating agency, arguing that credibility cannot be established by legislation alone. Therefore, for the foreseeable future, investors are likely to continue relying on established global rating agencies.

The solution, once again, returns to data.

Countries improve credibility by producing timely, transparent, and reliable information. Published data should be open to scrutiny and challenge. Where weaknesses are identified, they should be addressed through better measurement and stronger institutions.

Data transparency is not a courtesy extended by government to critics. It is the foundation of credible policymaking. A country that cannot accurately measure its tax effort, explain its inflation dynamics, or account for the performance of its public finances will face higher borrowing costs, weaker investor confidence, and slower economic progress.

The Jollof Index is a modest contribution to this broader effort. Over nearly a decade, it has broadly tracked official trends, provided additional market-level insights, and maintained methodological transparency. That commitment to evidence, transparency, and accountability is ultimately the standard to which all public data systems should be held.

Cheta Nwanze is a Partner at SBM Intelligence.