Risk Insight: Snap Inc. draws more similarities to Twitter than Facebook
We see Snap’s credit peers are Yelp and Twitter, as each of these firms had similar credit quality pre-IPO.
Snap Inc.’s initial public offering is so far one of the higher profile IPOs in 2017. Much of the attention is focused on the equity valuation of the company and its potential growth over the coming years, as well as what it means for future technology IPOs. However, in this blog, we will focus on an alternative perspective: what is the credit quality of this company, and where might it be headed in the future?
While Snap does not have publicly available debt, anyone with a stake in the firm who believes in Snap’s growth potential must also consider the downside risk that credit analysis provides. Certainly, those providing Snapchat’s parent, Snap Inc, with a $1.2bn revolving credit facility would have an interest in the company’s ability to pay back that amount if it were drawn down.
We compared Snap to several other high profile tech IPOs in recent years to see how they compared and if there were any potential implications for the firms. Specifically, we compared Snap to Yelp, Twitter, and Facebook during the period of their IPOs and in subsequent quarters.
Snap’s credit model score
We undertake this analysis by utilizing our credit scoring model, CreditModel, an advanced statistical model by S&P Global Market Intelligence, designed to generate a quantitative credit score that approximates a credit rating by S&P Global Ratings. When scoring Snap, we calculate that the firm has an implied credit score of ‘b’.
Snap’s credit score denotes elevated credit risk; more specifically, it would equate to a 4.45% observed default rate over a one year period, or nearly a one in 20 occurrence of default. To put that into perspective, Snap’s credit score is more risky than the median level of risk in the Application Software industry, which is ‘b+.’
As a result of the analysis, we see Snap’s credit peers are Yelp and Twitter, as each of these firms had similar credit quality pre-IPO. Once public, the cash infusion from the IPO provided a short term credit boost, increasing their credit scores immediately, and then ongoing improvements in financial performance continued this increase in subsequent quarters. For example, for Twitter, this occurred as assets rose from $1bn to $3.4bn after the IPO, and the contribution to overall risk for this risk factor dropped from 33% to 17% as the credit score improved. If Snap were to follow a similar pattern, their credit health could improve over the coming quarters and buoy their longer term prospects from a financial health point of view.
In Chart 1, we can see the historical credit scores for Yelp, Twitter and Facebook before and after their respective IPOs. Yelp and Twitter had credit scores in a similar range as Snap pre-IPO. Twitter’s credit score was the same ‘b’ and Yelp’s credit score was two notches lower at ‘ccc+’. However, post-IPO, both these firms exhibited an immediate one notch uptick in credit scores. In the longer term, as shown in Chart 1, their credit scores rose more substantially, as Twitter’s score rose another notch to ‘bb-‘ and Yelp’s score rose five additional notches to ‘bb-‘ over the subsequent five years.
Facebook, by contrast, due to its relative size, profitability and cash reserves, held a credit score of ‘bbb+’ pre-IPO, an investment grade equivalent score. Their risk, by contrast did increase post-IPO, with the implied credit score dropping to ‘bbb-‘ in the next quarter, then down to ‘bb+’ before increasing back to ‘bbb+’ after a year. This drop in credit scores occurred alongside a broader shift in risk in the industry, where the median credit risk fell from ‘b+’ to ‘b’. Facebook’s score continued to rise in subsequent years, as high a ‘aa-‘ and most recently ‘a+’, solidly within the investment grade range.
How can Snap improve its credit quality?
If Snap were to look to the debt markets for funding in the future, an improvement in credit quality from ‘b’ would be advantageous to them. Twitter followed up on their IPO by issuing two corporate convertible notes totalling nearly $1.9bn in 2014, which were subsequently exchanged in 2015. This debt is rated ‘BB-‘ by S&P Global Ratings, the same as Twitter’s issuer credit rating and their CreditModel score, ‘bb-’.
How else can Snap improve on its credit quality? The majority of their calculated risk is driven by two main factors: a Return on Capital of negative 45.02% contributes 48% of the risk, and total assets of $1,722.7mm contributes 27%. Improved profitability, and, more specifically positive EBIT, as well as a greater asset base, would help drive an improvement in credit quality. These improvements would make the company’s financial condition more amenable to credit investors and more secure overall.
*Certain required inputs for our scoring model are not reported by Yelp. To model their credit risk, we have leveraged our imputation logic to approximate what the appropriate required financial ratios would be, and then calculated a credit score.
Jim Elder is Director, Risk Services, S&P Global Market Intelligence. Source: http://marketintelligence.spglobal.com
This article is published under the series Finance and Technology, a new platform of Financial Nigeria magazine, promoted by Simplex Business Solutions Limited. Knowledge leaders in the interception of finance and technology are welcome to contribute to the industry platform. Editorial contributions should be submitted to firstname.lastname@example.org.
The AU in 2012 established the African Risk Capacity as an African solution for Africa.
As Dr. Okonjo-Iweala rightly said, poverty is bad for growth.
Let’s be clear: The movement of those that want a better and different Nigeria – to which I belong ...
The Misery Index is a simple-enough metric that a busy president can understand at a glance.
The Federal Ministry of Science and Technology is expected to establish centres for technology acquisition in the six ...
His victory would be uniquely capable of stirring our individual and collective “can-do” spirit, erasing ...
Most Popular News
- Details of President Muhammadu Buhari's "Budget of Change"
- Fundamentals that every new forex trader should be aware of
- Nigeria, Morocco sign agreements on regional gas pipeline, chemical plant
- FDI to Africa falls by 21 percent, says UNCTAD 2018 World Investment Report
- Ivory Coast and Ghana set to harmonize sales strategy for cocoa
- Inflation continues downward trend, drops to 11.61 percent in May